Civil Appeal

Civil Appeals Lawyer - Appeal a Civil Case in California

Losing a civil case can feel like the end of the road, but in many situations, there is a legal path forward. A civil appeal allows you to challenge errors made during your trial-whether in business litigation, property disputes, probate matters, or other civil cases. Our firm represents clients in Santa Cruz, Monterey County, and across California in carefully crafted appeals aimed at correcting those mistakes and pursuing a better outcome.

Appealing a Civil Case Verdict

Civil appeals focus on legal and procedural errors-not on re-trying the case. We thoroughly review trial transcripts, court rulings, and key evidence to determine whether the trial court misapplied the law or violated procedural rules. Whether the matter involves a contract dispute, a probate judgment, or a complex business lawsuit, we handle the appellate process from start to finish, ensuring each argument is supported by strong legal authority.

Legal Error

A judge applied the wrong legal standard, misinterpreted a statute, or gave incorrect jury instructions.

Insufficient Evidence

The verdict lacked substantial evidence to support it (a challenging but sometimes valid basis for appeal).

Procedural Misconduct 

Juror bias, attorney misconduct, or other procedural errors that were not corrected during trial.

Abuse of Discretion

The trial court's decision on evidence, damages, or other key issues was unreasonable or arbitrary.

Our Civil Appellate Experience

We have handled civil appeals arising from business disputes, real estate conflicts, and probate proceedings. In one notable matter, we persuaded the Court of Appeal to reverse a judgment by demonstrating that the trial court misinterpreted a central statute. Whether the goal is to overturn an unfavorable verdict or defend a judgment on appeal, our focus is on precise legal analysis and persuasive written advocacy.

Working with Trial Counsel

Many appeals come to us after another lawyer handled the trial. We work respectfully with your trial attorney, ensuring they remain informed and involved if you wish. In some cases, we take over the appeal entirely; in others, we collaborate closely, combining their in-depth factual knowledge with our appellate strategy and writing skills.

The Appeals Timeline

A civil appeal in California typically involves:


  1. Filing a Notice of Appeal - Usually within about 60 days of the judgment.
  2. Preparing the Record - Compiling the clerk's and reporter's transcripts.
  3. Briefing - We draft the appellant's opening brief, the respondent replies, and we may file a reply brief.
  4. Oral Argument - Presenting the case before the appellate judges.
  5. Decision - The court issues a ruling, which can take months after oral argument.

Appeals are deliberate and time-consuming, but we guide clients through each step with clear communication.

Civil Appeals FAQ

  • Do I have to pay the judgment while the appeal is pending?

    Not if you obtain a stay by posting an appeal bond for money judgments. We can help arrange this to pause enforcement during your appeal.

  • What does an appellate brief look like?

    It's a detailed written argument-often 25 to 50 pages-explaining the trial errors and citing legal authority. We prepare briefs that are concise, clear, and persuasive.

  • Can a settlement happen during an appeal?

    Yes. Many cases settle while on appeal, sometimes because the appellate process creates leverage for negotiation. We can pursue settlement talks when appropriate.

Take the Next Step

If you believe your civil trial was decided in error, don't wait-appeal deadlines are short. We provide candid evaluations and build compelling appellate arguments to protect your rights.

55 River Street, Suite 100, Santa Cruz, CA